Giveaway Contest - Win the Fantastic Finger Guides!!! Entering is easy, scroll down to learn how. After almost a decade of teaching, Toby Weston, educator & creator of the Fantastic Finger Guides asked himself: Why do we use finger tapes when first learning to play string instruments such as the violin, viola, or cello? Is there a better way than finger tapes to get our beginners playing correctly with musical confidence? Learn more about why using pitches instead of finger numbers is empowering to the learning process below by guest blog post author Toby Weston. I have learned from teaching middle school music for the past 12 years that the best way to improve student learning is to improve the teaching system. I wondered if there was a better way to teach than with finger tapes because finger tapes don't provide sufficient musical information to help the student grow musically smarter and they are a very abstract teaching tool. I was concerned that by using finger tapes, my students were labeling the sound only by its physical location and not coding the actual musical language. At one point I used different color tapes for different locations: 1st finger was red, 2nd finger was white, and the 3rd finger was blue. After a year of playing, most students using this system will code the location as 1st finger on the red tape on the A string, but not code the letter name nor musical language. By the time these students reached the 7th grade, many had deficiencies in understanding their fingerboard in terms of a musical alphabet. After years of using finger tapes I had a breakthrough in the Fall of 2017: Why don't we just put the letter names on the instrument? This way the student has the information needed to move forward in the music. When a student practices on their own they build correct muscle memory for spacing and also musical alphabet memory. This leads to gaining confidence in their playing without their teacher present. The student can code the music alphabet as their primary thinking versus finger tapes that are too abstract and don't provide any musical information. I ended up creating the Fantastic Finger Guides to solve this problem for my students. I created the D Major Beginner Guide for my first-year students and the All Notes guide for my second-year students. When students are beginning to learn the violin, less is better thus the rationale for a more simplified finger guide. Receive 10% off the Fantastic Finger Guides thru July 31, 2020 with coupon code MFYV2020. Click HERE to order the Fantastic Finger Guides. How To Enter the Fantastic Finger Guide Giveaway Contest:
145 Comments
Joy Anna
6/22/2020 03:18:48 pm
Teacher -letters
Reply
Heather
6/23/2020 09:25:04 am
Thanks Joy & thanks for being the 1st to enter the contest! Best wishes with your music, Heather
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 10:12:47 am
Thanks Jennifer for entering and posting! HF
Sally Riman
6/28/2020 04:07:15 pm
I use tapes and letter names. My students do written theory lessons, just as my piano students do. I also have a chart for the strings on the wall, so it can be a visual thing, too.
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 10:13:39 am
Hello - Your student are fortunate to have this well rounded music education. Thanks and keep up the great work! HF
Chris
6/28/2020 08:20:30 pm
Combination! Finger numbers for younger students but also talking , about the names
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 10:14:04 am
Hi Chris - Thanks for posting and best wishes! HF
Kristen Day
6/29/2020 09:51:43 am
Teacher- letters of course!
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 10:14:35 am
Thank you Kristen! best wishes, HF
Margaret Lewis
6/22/2020 03:19:28 pm
Teacher - Letters
Reply
Heather
6/23/2020 09:25:45 am
Thanks Margaret & best wishes with your music making! Heather
Reply
Evelyn
6/22/2020 03:26:58 pm
Teacher & student :) - letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:26:28 am
Thanks Evelyn & best wishes with your music making both learning and teching! Heather
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:27:19 am
Thanks Teresa & best wishes with your music making! Heather
Reply
Andrew
6/22/2020 04:59:04 pm
Teacher. Letters seems the logical choice. Thank you in advance
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:27:44 am
Thanks Andrew & best wishes with your music making! Heather
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:28:12 am
Thanks Tanya & best wishes with your music making! Heather
Reply
Lori
6/22/2020 06:56:18 pm
Teacher—letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:28:55 am
Thanks Lori - this seems to be the preferred choice. Best wishes!
Reply
Elizabeth Cunha
6/22/2020 07:02:31 pm
Teacher. Numbers first on instrument but letters simultaneously without instrument. Letters come quickly.
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:29:40 am
Love this approach - the best of both worlds. Thanks Elizabeth!
Reply
Ellen M Burrows
6/22/2020 07:03:46 pm
Teacher, and I use both but gravitate to numbers
Reply
heatherfigi
6/23/2020 09:30:17 am
Thanks so much for commenting - best wishes! Heather
Reply
Connie Meekhof
6/22/2020 07:06:45 pm
Teacher - letters. Thanks so much!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:30:45 am
Great Connie! Thanks, Heather
Reply
Marie Anderson
6/22/2020 07:08:02 pm
Teacher- letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:31:06 am
Thanks Marie & best wishes with your music making! Heather
Reply
Jenna O'Connor
6/22/2020 07:08:08 pm
Teacher - letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:31:41 am
Thanks for entering the contest Jenna!
Reply
Bethany
6/22/2020 07:09:39 pm
Student ~ letters.
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:40:08 am
Thanks for being the 1st STUDENT to comment - great feedback & best wishes, Heather
Reply
Tina Raimondi
6/22/2020 07:10:12 pm
Teacher and Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 09:40:54 am
Hi Tina, thanks for the feedback and for entering the contest, BEST WISHES, Heather
Reply
Amy Robinson
6/22/2020 07:18:19 pm
Teacher- letters!
Reply
hEATHER
6/23/2020 12:25:28 pm
Thanks for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Regine Maier
6/22/2020 07:28:16 pm
Teacher-letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:26:04 pm
Thanks Regine for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
June Pockrus
6/22/2020 07:48:50 pm
Letters are a wonderful idea. Is there a true/accurate way to hit that first note spot on without numbers or letters?
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:26:33 pm
Great attitude June! Thanks
Reply
Laura
6/22/2020 07:49:58 pm
Student, not sure which would be better, but I think letters would probably be easier. Thank you!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:27:12 pm
Hi Laura - thanks for entering the contest and good luck! Heather
Reply
Colleen Snyder
6/22/2020 08:06:40 pm
I am a teacher and I use both numbers and letters. eg. “This note is a C sharp - regular 2 on the A string. Or, what is the name of this note? If the student answers “2” - then I respond, yes, it is a 2 on the A string but what is its letter name? Is it a regular 2 or a low 2?
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:27:54 pm
Great work Colleen - I love how you expand this for your students!
Reply
6/22/2020 09:02:25 pm
Teacher, both numbers and letters. I'm intrigued with this new method!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:28:41 pm
Thanks Anita - I am also intrigued & it reminds me how important it is to stay open minded. Best wishes, Heather
Reply
Sheila Fries
6/22/2020 09:16:24 pm
Teacher- letters!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:29:12 pm
Thanks Sheila for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Sarah Beinart
6/22/2020 09:37:49 pm
Teacher - letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:31:08 pm
Thanks Sarah for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Arlyn
6/22/2020 09:38:03 pm
Teacher & Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:31:36 pm
Thanks Arlyn for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Rachelle Tam
6/22/2020 09:46:15 pm
Teacher - letters!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:34:01 pm
You have an outstanding attitude! Congrats on beginning your teaching career, best wishes, HF
Reply
Emily Lanzone
6/22/2020 10:11:24 pm
Teacher- letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:35:19 pm
Thanks Emily, I really appreciate you sharing your school's approach, I think many of us like to know what people are doing in their programs. Best wishes, HF
Reply
6/22/2020 10:13:48 pm
I have been using numbers so far but I like this idea! Thanks!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:35:52 pm
Thanks Lois- it really is some great food for thought.
Reply
Erlie May Scherling
6/22/2020 10:47:51 pm
STUDENT & Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:36:26 pm
Thanks Erlie! We love hearing from students here. Best wishes, Heather
Reply
Joanne Richardson
6/23/2020 03:31:08 am
Teacher - elementary school string orchestra program
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:37:02 pm
Thanks Joanne - I appreciate your comment and the context you shared. Best wishes, Heather
Reply
Lois O'Brien
6/23/2020 03:42:13 am
Teacher—letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:41:19 pm
Thanks Lois for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Angela Stock
6/23/2020 05:53:27 am
STUDENT & Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:42:09 pm
Thanks Angela - We love hearing from enthusiastic students like yourself. Best wishes, HF
Reply
Sandra Cole Blocker
6/23/2020 06:18:41 am
Student! I would love this system. I am a Book 1 adult student of the violin (lifelong dream) Suzuki method. It's a terrific way to learn, but I am now transitioning from the "finger/tape system" to note reading. This "relearn" replacement layer of musical literacy could be skipped if I started with a tool like these tapes. Now I am incorporating the "I Can Rad Music" lessons into my practice. Which is more reading and less playing. I would love to win these (hint!)
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:45:47 pm
I am so excited for you and sounds like you are off to an exciting start! The I Can Read Music series is outstanding. I have used these for decades w/great results. Best wishes, HF
Reply
William Young
6/23/2020 07:03:17 am
Student - Letters please
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:46:20 pm
Thanks William for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Alison
6/23/2020 07:08:45 am
Teacher- letters and numbers
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:46:51 pm
Thanks Alison for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
D Ann Wood
6/23/2020 07:43:41 am
Teacher - Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:48:32 pm
Thanks D'Ann for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Abigail C.
6/23/2020 07:46:14 am
Teacher - Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:52:44 pm
Thanks Abigail for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Melissa S Fees
6/23/2020 09:28:17 am
student letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:51:46 pm
Great - thanks Melissa!
Reply
Ivie Etkins-Turner
6/23/2020 09:44:40 am
Teacher, Letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:51:19 pm
Thanks Ivie for the comment and entering the giveaway contest, best wishes! Heather
Reply
Adrian Bhatti
6/23/2020 09:57:53 am
Teacher - would love both letters and numbers!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:50:52 pm
Thanks Adrian!!!
Reply
Diede Drijfhout
6/23/2020 10:07:36 am
Teacher & Student - Letters, but I use numbers to clarify. Lovely idea, it would work for a lot of different learning styles too!
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:50:22 pm
Thank you so much for the comment and letting us know your process. It's so interesting to hear from all the teachers here. Best Wishes!
Reply
Joie
6/23/2020 12:24:26 pm
Teacher - both, numbers at first and transition to letters
Reply
heather
6/23/2020 12:49:28 pm
Thanks for sharing - I like that you are using both modalities. Best wishes, HF
Reply
Claudia
6/23/2020 01:17:58 pm
Student - Letters!
Reply
Claudia
6/23/2020 01:30:06 pm
I am a Student. I prefer Letters.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:24:01 am
Thanks Claudia & best wishes with your studies!
Reply
Cheri
6/23/2020 05:53:36 pm
Adult beginner STUDENT. I would prefer LETTERS (notes) .
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:23:23 am
I love hearing from an adult beginner. Thanks so much for posting!
Reply
Emily
6/24/2020 05:20:30 am
Student- letters
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:22:50 am
Thanks Emily - Best wishes!
Reply
Gaby Iglesias
6/24/2020 08:20:20 am
Teacher, Letters! Great Idea, thanks!!
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:22:19 am
Thanks Gaby :)
Reply
PAULA WITNEY
6/24/2020 07:50:11 pm
teacher-students, letters
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:21:53 am
Great Paula, Thanks for posting.
Reply
Suzi
6/25/2020 02:46:28 pm
Beginner Student - 3 months
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:21:19 am
Thanks Suzi - We love hearing your feedback. Best wishes, Heather
Reply
6/25/2020 03:42:44 pm
Fantastic tool although tapes work very well when using the Suzuki method, when you start introducing sharps, flats and naturals the tape will translate most of the theory into practical especially when playing scales and exercises on the finger board.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:20:40 am
Great feedback Emmanuel! Thanks so much for sharing this. Best wishes, Heather
Reply
Bev
6/25/2020 09:21:12 pm
I am a teacher in Australia. I have found some students prefer to use numbers and others go straight into letter names.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:17:33 am
Thanks Bev - I appreciate you sharing this and being flexible in your approach. Heather
Reply
Joy
6/26/2020 07:15:29 am
TEACHER : letters
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:16:49 am
Thanks Joy!
Reply
6/27/2020 07:47:04 am
Teacher - I use both. I specialize in teaching children with special needs. I have found that numbers work better with some students because they have issues with decoding letters.
Reply
HEATHER
6/28/2020 09:16:28 am
Hello Kelly, I am especially grateful that you shared this aspect. I believe that we will best help our students by being fluent in different approaches. Thank you so much for posting this. Heather
Reply
Brian Nitschke
6/27/2020 09:12:51 am
Teacher. Letters.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 09:09:02 am
Thanks Brian - I appreciate the comment & best wishes, Heather
Reply
Joe Chan
6/28/2020 10:48:06 am
Teacher- letters
Reply
Sister Marie-Therese Swiezynski
6/28/2020 11:07:22 am
Hello! I have been teaching for 30+ yrs. I actually use solfege syllables 1st as we learn each key. It helps students to always know where the half steps are, and it helps intonation. I often ask them to sing. I find that students can more easily learn difficult keys and different positions this way. With new positions, we usually do 1 octave scales with 1st finger "do." We learn letter names later.
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:50:15 am
Hello - Thank you so much for posting. This could be an entire discussion in itself. I personally was not exposed to Sol Feg until late 20s. I love that is connect the voice and helps identify roles within the scale system. Great insights, thanks again! HF
Reply
6/28/2020 11:40:23 am
Modified Suzuki program in the schools starting in kindergarten.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 01:26:51 pm
Hi Julie - I love that you have such clear parameters. Thanks for sharing this with all of us. Great feedback. Best wishes, HF
Reply
6/28/2020 12:09:32 pm
I start with numbers because the students need to understand fingerings, but we sings letters and sol feeds to learn letters before actually reading and writing notes.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 01:25:42 pm
Thanks Virginia- I appreciate that you are adding in the vocal component. When the ear hears it's own voice, there is a feedback loop and deeper connection made in the mind. You are very wise in your approach! Best wishes, HF
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 01:23:49 pm
Thanks Susan! Best wishes, HF
Reply
Sarah Lang
6/28/2020 12:31:14 pm
I am a teacher and I use both. I usually start out with finger numbers but add letters by mid-Book 1.
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 01:23:01 pm
Thanks Sarah - I appreciate your sharing the developmental level where you switch. Best wishes, HF
Reply
Sarah
6/28/2020 01:07:22 pm
Teacher, and most definitely letters!
Reply
heather
6/28/2020 01:22:08 pm
Thanks Sarah! Best wishes, HF
Reply
Heather
6/28/2020 01:30:40 pm
I think letters are better in the long run, but I will admit to alternating between letters and numbers with my students. With the really small kids, (3&4 year olds) I do finger numbers to start as they have enough challenge figuring out which is their third finger in the first place! I have discovered the hard way that if we don’t start talking about B natural and F# really early on, it can lead to a whole lot of confusion later on!!
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:48:00 am
Hi Heather - I also learned the hard way about this. I wonder if my own struggles with music theory contributed to this. Great insights and I love your ability to self-reflect. Thanks! HF
Reply
Danyl
6/28/2020 03:13:30 pm
Student - letters for myself, however my dyslexic son has a much easier time with numbers
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:46:59 am
Thanks Danyl - I appreciate your post because it helps us remember that not musician learn the same way. It's so important to keep this in our mind when helping students learn. Best wishes, HF
Reply
Val
6/28/2020 03:20:10 pm
I teach both letters and numbers. When playing a scale students say the name of the notes, including sharp or flats,. I use a whiteboard, kids love these and put up notes. Ask which note and if they give me the letter, I ask them which finger they would use to play this note and vice versa. I make up music stories, where they make up words from the notes displayed on the staff. I find musical games and singing helps greatly with the learning of the notes. Students love them especially the very young ones and they learn very quickly. I teach from home, love my job.
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:45:34 am
So many great ideas in this post - THANKS! I can tell you love your job. Keep up the inspired work, Heather
Reply
Janet
6/28/2020 06:05:09 pm
I teach both letter names and finger names, but have never thought to put the names on the fingerboard. Interesting idea!
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:44:34 am
Agreed - interesting idea and it made me think. Best wishes and thanks for posting! HF
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:43:53 am
Thanks Heather - Me too! HF
Reply
Leah
6/28/2020 09:15:21 pm
I am a parent (and student)-my daughter would say finger #s and I would say notes.
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:43:29 am
Thanks Leah - This is insightful. Appreciated! HF
Reply
Leslie
6/28/2020 11:42:02 pm
Teacher-finger tapes but would prefer the letters.
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:43:00 am
Great Leslie - Thanks for sharing. Best wishes, HF
Reply
Kathleen Vitevitch
6/29/2020 07:53:23 am
Teacher- Letters
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 09:42:25 am
Thanks Kathleen!
Reply
Kristina
6/29/2020 09:13:00 am
Teacher: I start with finger numbers, but within a few weeks teach letter names. Within about 6 weeks, I want them to easily find every letter in the basic 1st position pattern. Then we use both numbers and letters.
Reply
heather
6/29/2020 10:02:18 am
Thanks Kristina! Great insights and I love that you have a clear idea of what you seek in your curriculum. Keep it up! HF
Reply
Hallie
6/29/2020 12:46:24 pm
Student, Letters
Reply
10/30/2022 08:47:33 pm
I start with numbers, but add letters as soon as all three fingers are used on the A string - that way we can correlate finger numbers with the musical alphabet since the first scale they learn is A major. A, then 1st finger is B, etc.
Reply
heather
10/31/2022 04:39:30 pm
Thanks for sharing this feedback!
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Categories
All
Archives
February 2024
AuthorHi! It's me, Heather. I absolutely love working on the Music for Young Violinists project and all the many facets: blogging, website, music, teaching materials, freebies, videos, newsletter and giveaway contests. The best part is connecting with you so feel free to drop me a line. You can learn more about me on the "ABOUT" page. Thanks! |